They're okay. They sort of remind me of my great aunt and what she would have at her home as kids.

I'd rather give and receive cookies baked for me then bought.

If they taste really good, yes. I actually like the old fashioned and formal boxes.

What I would do was buy a pretty fancy tin, and fill it with homemade cookies. Next I would tie it with a ribbon and send that as a gift.

I agree with aimeeb and Party. Better when they come from you.

i'm not one to really buy those things on my own but i've received quite a few from other people. in my industry, we get lots of gifts like that from reps , so my co-workers and i get to enjoy them.

I don't think I've ever bought any, but if they looked good, I suppose I might.

I love the blue tins with those buttercookies inside....sounds fat but SOOO GOOD!

Christmas- always at christmas do my family give/recieve tins of biscuits- the perfect lazy gift for the person you have no idea for

The key word is "tin", one of the cheapest metals there is. Cheap metal, cheap cookie.

we have these in france and i'm telling you they aren't worth 35 dollars!
Even macaroons aren't that expensive!

If the cookies are good, why not?! I have no issue with it.

they look really delicious!! i probably wouldn't buy them all the time, but everyone once in a while...

Maybe as a gift for someone who lived far away.

Evidently none of you has had cookies from Byrd Cookie Company. They come in a plethora of tins, some with beach scenes, some with scenes of Historic Savannah, some of Charleston. They are all very good, but my all time favorite are the Key Lime Coolers. They are to die for. Another would be the Benne Wafers. Just Google Byrd Cookie Co. or The Gourmet Marketplace. If I knew how to post them on here I would. And the tins become collector's items! Enjoy!

Nah. I generally don't really like crunchy cookies. Not worth it to me.

For a special gift I might, but most of the time my family and friends appreciate homebaked more. Many homemade cookie doughs can be kept in the freezer, if there is room. It can be is as easy as the premade rolls of dough from the market, and resale stores have some good bargains on tins, plates and baskets to use for gifting. My late wonderful aunt gave me some very good advice, to make one thing well and then "accessorize" with the packaging.