Well, I don't mind commenting. I'm surprised that Paula is up there higher than some of those women, but then, maybe the list is about more than just looks!

That's a super random list. Robin Miller??? Come on.

I'd like to know the criteria for qualifying for this list.

Too bad Stuff Magazine folded today and will now be just a section inside Maxim.

Well, not really too bad (other than for people who lost jobs, of course), because do we certainly don't need any more arbitrary lists ranking womens hotness.

Everytime Paula comes on I have to switch the channel. She drives me NUTSO. My husband and I call Giada Pacman...you know, that strange square smile she has!

cat cora is totally hotter than elie krieger or robin miller.

and paula's deen's sons should win for hottest guys....oh how i love me some jamie and bobby.

Paula is really seductive, but I would have had to give Rachael as the hottest, she is just so REAL, Giada seems a little fake to me (when you watch her on her travel shows, her real personality seems a little fake). But she is pretty.

I consider Nigella to be one of the sexiest women alive, period, on Food Network or off. It's sad (and surprising) that she's not #1...because if the list was picked by men (which I'm pretty sure it was, being in Stuff) she is by far the most seductive of the network's stars. Most people I know call her show "Food Porn."

Ha ha-- I love that Paula Deen's #2! Who needs youth and good looks when you can have a lady who uses a stick of butter in every dishes?
But anyway, Tyler Florence is a fine piece of man.

Can we make our own top 10 men of food network?

I call her "Giadasaurus Rex" because of her short arms and giant jaw of teeth.

I love Paula Deen! I'm glad she was number 2. There is a certain charm and beauty about her that I can't quite explain. I'm surprised that Rachael Ray was so low on the list. I love her! She should have been at least top five.

Also, i agree with Ashlyn Rose. We need to make a top 10 list of the men of food network!

Giada looks like a witch with that nose of hers and I can't figure out why I have to be blinded by her cleavage everytime she's on TV.

Paula is higher than Nigella?

I love Giada. she's my fav, so I'm glad she won! and leaving a comment saying how commenting is "stupid" is really smart davidv1.

Lol, ranking Paula as #2 was funny! I love her even though her food might be a little too Southern for me sometimes!

Besides her, I like Giada, Nigella, and Ellie Krieger.

Nigella is a goddess..

Haha, my boyfriend would agree with the #1--I'd personally pick Nigella, but that's just my opinion.

Tyler Florence would be my #1 Food Network guy-I met him back in '05 and the guy is just gorgeous in person. His smile, his build, everything! And to top that all off he's totally sweet. Ugh. I was speechless in front of him though.

Nigella is clearly the sexiest babe on the whole network (and possibly all of the UK.) I love me some Giada, but she's jolie laide, let's face it.

Are they serious? Ina Garten? What? That lady is as exciting to watch as paint drying.

Nigella would be #1 if I had to do this list. Rachael Ray and Giada wouldn't even make my top 50.

ina garten makes cute puppies cry... and i don't care that much for her, either

ina garten IS THE BEST!!
and are you really asking the criteria for making the list? it's stuff magazine ... everything they write is a joke!
it's just supposed to be funny as far as i can tell.

Clearly, Nigella should be number one.
That list is totally busted, anyways.
Ya'll may think Ina is boring but she makes some of the best stuff.
Sandra Lee looks like a Stepford Wife but the food she makes is disgusting.

Rachel Ray is the most annoying person on Food Network. I can't change the channel fast enough when she comes on.

oh AGREED on sandra lee, eat your veggies. plus, the way she accessorizes herself and her kitchen based on the theme of the show drives me BONKERS.

hmm, my top would being giada and rachel, love those two!! and of course paula cuz she's freaking hilarious. ina and sarah lee annoy the hell out of me! man...

why did they feel the need to critize ina garten's looks and noone else's?
Mind you, she was probably pretty when she was thinner and younger.

Paula Dean # 2??? What has this world come to? If everyone wearing beer goggles or something?