With the writers' strike putting a pause on my favorite television series plot, I've started watching repeats of Gossip Girl. I recently caught the pilot and came across a scene in which Chuck feeds a drunk Serena a grilled cheese sandwich from his hotel's kitchen.
Not your ordinary grilled cheese — it's actually on the New York Palace Hotel's restaurant menu — this sandwich costs $50. So what makes it so divinely delicious and extra expensive? Thick-cut housemade bread, imported Italian Fontina cheese, and fresh shaved black truffles. To take a look at a clip from the episode and check out the recipe, read more.

Gossip Girl's Grilled Cheese Sandwich
From Christopher Lee
8 slices of fresh baked white bread (look for a local bakery)
16 slices of fontina cheese
2 tbsp sweet butter
2 oz fresh shaved black winter truffles
salt and pepper, to taste
- Layer 2 slices of fontina cheese between 2 slices of white bread and shave a couple of slices of truffles in the middle of each sandwich; do the same for all four sandwiches.
- Heat a large fry pan over medium heat and add the butter.
- When the butter melts, add the sandwiches and cook until the bread is nice and toasted.
- Remove and slice sandwiches in half and place into four plates.
Makes 4 sandwiches.
Print recipe with images | without images






Tory Burch
1881 Cerruti Blue
Cosmence
I would never pay $50 for a grilled cheese! I'd rather eat lobster!
1I can make a grilled cheesed for less than 3 bucks.There is no way I would pay that much for one.
2Mmmm, truffles. Sooo good!
3There a place in Brooklyn that uses truffle oil instead of butter for their grilled cheese. This is like heaven on a plate. I could do shots of truffle oil...drool.
4so i just learned that truffles were mushrooms and not chocolate... because i'm not going to lie... chocolate smothered grilled cheese? awkward...
5$50 for a grilled cheese?? Uhhhh no.
6I must make this sandwich!
7Cheese covered chocolate. Don't worry, the first time I heard about truffles, I thought chocolate too ... now do I have any truffles about? But, darn this sandwich does sound good, and I really like grilled cheese ... I do have truffle oil in the house ... kitchen here I come!
8This story just inspired me to made a grilled cheese for dinner, but since i dislike truffle i made mine with grilled pears and caramelized onions!
9where in Brooklyn? I must go!
10Chicsugar- I'll ask my friend for the name. It's in Williamsburg around N 7th and Bedford.
11this would be the BEST hangover food. haha. an expensive one tho.
12Thank you DearMissPriss!!
13i'm gonna hav to try this...
14Chicsugar, it's called Blackbird Parlour. It's on Bedford between N 6th & 7th. I will prolly see you there!
15That sounds delicious and I'd be down for $50 grilled cheese any day.
16Sounds like it might be good
17It better be the size of my head
18lol @ missyd!!
19I would so try it!! Just once or maybe again on a special occasion.
20ha, #5 and #8! i always thought of truffles as the mushrooms, so i was confused too the first time i heard the term used to refer to chocolates!
21Mmmmmmmmmm! sounds YUMMY!!
22grilled cheese w/ truffles/truffle oil is sooooooo good...i've only had them once at princeton houseparties
23Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.