Last week my girlfriend Kristal inherited 80 bottles of wine. She invited me over to browse the boxes and taste some of the vintages. The bulk of the wine was from the late '80s and early to mid 90s. While we immediately spotted a couple of valuable bottles, the vast majority were bottles we knew nothing about. Our main concern was finding out if the wine was drinkable. Not all wine is ideal for storing. If it's been in contact with air for too long or has a tainted cork, the liquid inside has turned and should not be consumed. To find out the signs that show a good wine has gone bad, read more.
- The smell is off. If a wine's aroma is moldy or resembles a musty basement, wet cardboard, or vinegar, it's turned. A heavy raisin smell is another bad signal.
- Avoid red wines that are not Port, but have the aroma typically characteristic of Port. When wine tastes like dessert wine, it has been overexposed to heat, and is therefore undrinkable.
- When the cork is pushed out slightly from the bottle, it's a sign the wine has overheated and expanded within the bottle.
- Examine the color. A brown hue in red wine demonstrates that the liquid is past its prime. White wines that have darkened to a deep yellow or brownish straw color are usually oxidized.
- Wine that lacks fruit, is raspy, too astringent, or has a paint-thinner taste is usually bad.
- A still wine that is fizzy or effervescent has undergone a second fermentation after the bottling and shouldn't be enjoyed.
- Although the term "corked" commonly refers to wine that has gone bad, inspecting the cork alone will not determine if the wine is tainted. Be sure to smell and examine the actual liquid.
Have you ever had an undrinkable bottle of wine? How did you know it had turned?






McQ by Alexander McQueen
this is really helpful. i'm just slowly starting to learn more and more about wine and it's always great to know when i should toss a bottle rather than make myself miserable drinking it.
1mmm... wine.
2this is so helpful, thank you! Now I can determine if I should use all this wine for sauces or if it is good drinking wine!
3Good to know...I always wondered how you could tell.
4i never throw away wine- then again, never had a fizzy bottle... lol. if it's really sour smelling, why not try making your own vinegar? i have a large glass container i keep all my old wine in to ferment into vinegar, and use it in salad dressings and marinades instead of the store bought stuff. you could also check to see if a friend makes some- they would appreciate the overstock, no doubt.
5Thanks for this! I've just started getting into and learning about wine and I've always wondered if I'd know if it was bad wine.
6Party: I'm curious to know how many of the bottles you wound up keeping!
7I don't drink a lot of wine, but my parents drink it on occasion. Usually, my dad will forget about a bottle of wine in the fridge and it'll turn into wine vinegar over time...it's not terrible, but it's not something you'd want to drink straight up.
8We've had bad bottles of wine that my husband detects by the dried out cork or basically by taste. Never had any 'fizzy' wine though- thank goodness. Lots of good info here- thanks
9Party...I thought you never had left over wine.
10I rarely store wine but this is still really good to know
11My husband and I had a case of wine that we loved and were so bummed when half of it had that fizzy thing going on. Glad to know I wasn't crazy when I said "it tastes like its carbonated". I would hope anyone that encountered a wine that tasted like paint thinner might know that something is wrong
12I'm with Yum, how many were still good?
13I like the idea of just using "bad wine" for good vinegar. Unless there is some health reason not to (anyone know?)
14good to know.
15Girls we didn't open them all! We tried like 3 bottles and they were all good.
16Last year on New Year's Eve, my dad got a bottle of bubbly out of the basement and struggled for a long time to get the cork out. Then instead of popping out, the cork just plopped into his hand with a sad little "Ffft". He poured a glass, and the wine was dark brown! It was so gross, but we were all cracking up. Of course we dumped the wine!
You can see the video of it here, haha:
17http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pjAxUiQZHig
Oh, and that's me in the Boston sweatshirt in the video
18I had a bad bottle of red wine once. Unfortunately, I just opened the bottle, poured a glass and took a swig only to find the wine completely rancid. d-i-s-g-u-s-t-i-n-g.
19I'd never gotten a bad bottle until about two weeks ago. The wine looked fine, but it tasted and smelled like vinegar. So sad to have to throw it out.
20Also, you're right suziryder, that was a rather hilariously anticlimactic champagne popping.
21This is pretty misleading advice overall.
22- How about an aged Meursault? Is that not deep golden yellow? you wouldn't want to throw that down the sink.
- aged claret also often has a brownish tinge to it, even when aged to it's prime
- to say a small amount of effervescence in wime means it is off is totally inaccurate. there are many great wines that are supposed to have what is called 'spritz'. Undesireable effervescence also exists, but will cause unpleasant flavours in the wine so shoudl be easier to spot.
- a wine that lacks fruit may just be a poor wine, not an off wine
A friend gave my boyfriend like 8 bottles of homemade red wine this winter. We cracked one open and it smelled weird but we just thought it was because it was homemade... well it tasted like drinking a cup of vinegar or something. I had never had a glass of wine that was bad, but you know it the second you open the bottle and smell it.
23I like the idea of using old wine as vinegar. This was very informative. Thanks!
24Magicflute, Julia Child used to say that you should never cook with wine that you wouldn't drink! So if it's bad, it's bad. Just toss it or return it to the store where you bought it if it's a recent purchase.
25Very helpful! I've been looking for pointers like these for a while now.
26There is a difference between wine cheap wine and wine that has gone bad-
Ive had plenty of cheap wines that were very drinkable-and plenty that were 'fizzy' and they were meant to be.
If you taste wine that has gone bad you will know! You will probably gag when you smell or taste it.
Its just like drinking bad milk. You will know when its gone bad...
27I was given about 8 bottles of wine from S. Africa and cautioned that they may have gone bad by my aunt. Some wines just aren't meant to stored for very long periods of time. Boy was she right! The whites smelled like vinegar and the reds were brown. The cork falling to pieces upon extraction should have been the first sign. Also, if a cork has mildew on top, I think this may indicate a good time to toss it out with the dirty diapers. I was so looking forward to showing off these expensive bottles to my friends. Oh, well...Yellow Tail anyone?
28Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.