Which Clam Chowder Reigns Supreme?

February 4, 2008

New York may have beaten New England at the Super Bowl, but I want to know who would've won the chowder bowl? Would New York (aka Manhattan) clam chowder take home the prize or will New England clam chowder win it all? Vote for your team below!

Source

32 Comments

geohiker 5 years 14 weeks

mmmm - I just love Manhattan clam chowder! NE is okay, but too gooey and creamy for me. Give me clams and tomatoes, and I'm happy!

celebrity_soup 5 years 14 weeks

never heard of the red one before, doesnt look appealing either

celebrity_soup 5 years 14 weeks

the white creamy one, alllllllll the way!

amber_castaldo 5 years 15 weeks

white all the way

amber_castaldo 5 years 15 weeks

white all the way

UrbanBohemian 5 years 15 weeks

I love Clam Chowder!!!! And I love NE as well as NY :-)

colormesticky 5 years 15 weeks

I don't eat either one. And until just now, I'd never even seen the Manhattan before. I always wondered about that line in Ace Ventura. What's the password? "New England clam chowder" Is that the red, or the white? I was always like, WTF? Clam chowder doesn't come in red! You learn something every day.

colormesticky 5 years 15 weeks

I don't eat either one. And until just now, I'd never even seen the Manhattan before. I always wondered about that line in Ace Ventura.What's the password?"New England clam chowder"Is that the red, or the white?I was always like, WTF? Clam chowder doesn't come in red! You learn something every day.

sarahcateh 5 years 15 weeks

I HATE Manhattan clam chowder. Maybe I just haven't had the good stuff, but New England clam chowder (in a sourdough bowl) definitely takes the cake for me.

Marci 5 years 15 weeks

I knew I'd be in the minority with the Manhattan chowder, but I can't eat New England chowder anymore because of my diary allergies. Besides, I'm a New YAWKA, so I've got to stand behind my soup!

ALSW 5 years 15 weeks

No question. New England clam chowder - yum!

Random 5 years 15 weeks

My Dad makes really yummy Manhattan chowder, it's got a nice spice to it. Mmm.... love it.

xfortrenox 5 years 15 weeks

hatteras style blows both away...clear broth makes it much tastier.

Buffy2103 5 years 15 weeks

I like NE chowder better, but I would most likely eat Manhattan b/c its healthier.

CaterpillarGirl 5 years 15 weeks

i prefer manhattan myself.

CaterpillarGirl 5 years 15 weeks

i prefer manhattan myself.

laneylaney 5 years 15 weeks

born and bred in Manhattan but I still love a New England chowder more!

CiaoBella 5 years 15 weeks

Manhattan all the way! Yahoo! Giants!

bellaressa 5 years 15 weeks

I've never tried either; but from the picture, I would like to try both.

Linda McP 5 years 15 weeks

New England all the way!

Linda McP 5 years 15 weeks

New England all the way!

Swen 5 years 15 weeks

I love them both. New England, when good, is definitely my favorite. But it's kind of hit or miss. Bad New England is disgusting, but Manhattan is consistently good with any recipe.

Lambsauce 5 years 15 weeks

I've only ever had Manhattan clam chowder once... but that's only because it's so darn hard to find! I definitely prefer it.Voting for the underdog here!

Lambsauce 5 years 15 weeks

I've only ever had Manhattan clam chowder once... but that's only because it's so darn hard to find! I definitely prefer it. Voting for the underdog here!

Marseeah 5 years 15 weeks

I LOVE love love fattening foods. So... even though I'm a new yorker... I voted for NE clam chowder.

Link Love

32 Comments

You Might Also Like