Would You Eat This Sandwich?

January 22, 2008

While watching an episode of Diary of a Foodie on the new Gourmet website, I came across a very interesting sandwich.

The magazine's editor in chief, Ruth Reichl, was making The Max Special, a sandwich with peanut butter, mayonnaise, and pimento-stuffed olives. At first I thought, "gross!" Then I realized if Ms. Reichl is eating this sandwich, it must be pretty darn delicious. I plan on making one to see how it tastes.

What do you think? Would you eat this peanut butter, mayonnaise, and pimento-stuffed olive sandwich?

Source

Peanut Butter Gourmet Sandwiches Diary Of A Foodie Olives Mayonnaise Ruth Reichl Would You Eat This

78 Comments

2 years 6 weeks

I've made this sandwich, actually. I was surprised by it. I'm not a big fan. It's not actually disgusting, but it is an acquired taste. My daughter loves them, though. She makes them all the time, now.

2 years 17 weeks

Many residents area around Clark county IL have enjoyed this sandwich (buttered and grilled) for many years. It is one of my favorites! According to my Mother and Aunt, it was first served in that area by the local "Candy Kitchen", a gathering place for teens and high school students.

LilGlamDiva 4 years 7 weeks

I love olives and mayo, the only thing that would throw me is the PB. but I'd give it a try

puddlesworth 5 years 13 h

AmberHoney 5 years 15 weeks

I'm gonna try it and some of the other suggestions here sound pretty tasty.

Pepper 5 years 15 weeks

I'd give it a try.

daddio49 5 years 16 weeks

I'll try anything once...

CaterpillarGirl 5 years 16 weeks

I used to eat Peanut Butter Banana and Mayo sandwiches as a kid. i would try this

almostloli 5 years 16 weeks

i might try it..

haze1nut 5 years 16 weeks

YES! i'd try it if ruth reichl loves it!! she's a woman of unquestionable taste, i mean if she said it was delicious it must be!

michelleannette 5 years 16 weeks

i would try it...maybe it's delicious!

GlowingMoon 5 years 16 weeks

No, mayo makes me gag.

Stupidasscat 5 years 16 weeks

There might be something to it my son put miriclewhip and peanut butter togerher and said it was good

limelindsey 5 years 16 weeks

Peanut butter = yummy Pimento olives = yummy Mayo (GOOD mayo) = yummy So why am I not convinced this wouldn't be a gross out? IDK, I guess I'll have to try it!

tati33 5 years 16 weeks

no thanks

suziryder 5 years 16 weeks

Green olives make me want to throw up!

depeche3 5 years 16 weeks

So what are the results... was it good? I am curious now

techkim 5 years 16 weeks

At this point being pregnant its hard to say. I guess the peanut butter becomes the sweet and the green olives the salty. I don't know I might try it but stay close to the kitchen sink LOL.

ktownpolarbear 5 years 16 weeks

Well I like peanut butter. I like mayo. I don't really like olives. So I guess 2/3 isn't too bad, right?

caramelqtee75 5 years 16 weeks

I'm not sure who Ruth Reichel is, but I don't care if Patty LaBelle, Oprah or my Great Grandma was eating this mess, I wouldn't eat it.

caramelqtee75 5 years 16 weeks

HE!! no - yall nasty.

geohiker 5 years 16 weeks

I don't think this is my kind of sandwich, and i don't like mayo. But if Ruth offered me one, I'd try it! :)

kiwitwist 5 years 16 weeks

:sick:

Kristinh1012 5 years 16 weeks

Seriously, I SO wish that you would have tried this BEFORE you posted this, so you could have at least given a LITTLE bit of an idea of how it tastes! Especially since I just can NOT see myself actually going home and making it because my family might have me committed thinking I lost my mind.

king's queen 5 years 16 weeks

Not a big fan of olives. However, it could be a flavor combination that that might work. I'd give it a try, especially since it seems to be a favorite of someone who really knows her food.

Link Love

78 Comments

You Might Also Like