Would You Rather Eat Crunchy or Creamy Peanut Butter?

February 21, 2010

23 Comments

I like both, although I prefer creamy, as it preserves the illusion of eating whole roasted nuts. Am writing a book about the history of peanut butter; my website is www.creamyandcrunchy.com

2 years 41 weeks

its just wrong to eat crunchy

L0neLyHeArT 3 years 12 weeks

I like creamy peanut butter.

Monique Marie 3 years 12 weeks

Creamy is the best!!

suziryder 3 years 12 weeks

I prefer crunchy, but I like smooth almost just as much. I love peanut butter! Where I'm a big stickler is JIF v. Skippy. I hate Jif. I think it tastes off, funky, almost spoiled. I prefer Skippy natural or Trader Joe's valencia peanuts natural.

PinkNC 3 years 12 weeks

I like both.

GlowingMoon 3 years 12 weeks

These days, creamy. I go back and forth, though.

medenginer 3 years 12 weeks

Creamy

socalbeachgal 3 years 12 weeks

Crunchy please but usually buy creamy for my son so I don't eat it too often.

KadBunny 3 years 12 weeks

Creamy please! Mmm by the spoonful. :P

POPSUGAR Sex & Culture 3 years 12 weeks

I was juuuust talking about this today. Crunchy please!

Rancher'sGirl 3 years 12 weeks

Super Crunchy in cookies, creamy on my toast and in sandwiches...and fuzzles is spot on about creamy on toast with BACON BACON BACON! :drool:

fuzzles 3 years 12 weeks

Creamy. On toast. With...BACON! :true:

Spectra 3 years 12 weeks

Chunky! When we were growing up, my dad would only buy the chunky kind because that's what he liked. So it's kind of grown on me.

njg1rl65 3 years 12 weeks

Love creamy but use chunky when making peanut butter cookies.

HoneyBrown1976 3 years 12 weeks

Creamy. But, I must admit to having a crunchy phrase in my life.

limelindsey 3 years 12 weeks

Creamy! My mom found out early that I didn't like crunchy....she made me a PBJ for lunch when I was probably 3 years old. She looked at my plate afterwards and asked me what the little chunks were. I said I didn't like the rocks! I had eaten the entire sandwich but had spit the peanut chunks out! After that she had to buy two kinds of peanut butter. Good times.