Would You Rather Eat Pot Pie or Shepherd's Pie?

October 11, 2009

by partysugar 19

Source: Flickr Users gtrwndr87 and randomduck

19 Comments

CanadianAlissa 3 years 31 weeks

i dislike crust. No pie of any kind for me... Shepherd's Pie for me.

orangek8 3 years 31 weeks

Mmm, shepherd's for me, please.

Neuroticone 3 years 31 weeks

I've never had Shepherd Pie but it sounds good.

melissaS 3 years 31 weeks

I like them both, but if I had to pick one I would have to choose shepherd's pie. Gotta have mashed potatoes :)

limelindsey 3 years 31 weeks

Shepherd's pie! But mainly because I LOVE mashed potatoes. The insides are basically the same - meat, veggies, gravy.

Pallas Athena 3 years 31 weeks

I love both, but I think I'd rather have pot pie.

victork 3 years 31 weeks

Shephard's pie, but damn, this is one difficult toss up. While I like sweet pies, I'm never able to pass up a good savoury pie. While it may not follow the shephard's pie recipe to the letter, I love the mash up of having a pastry bottom with the shephard pie top.

Spectra 3 years 31 weeks

I don't eat lamb/sheep so shepherd's pie is out for me. I don't eat pot pie either though...I just don't really care much for savory pies, I guess.

lindz72486 3 years 31 weeks

Both are good, but I prefer pot pie the PA Dutch way with dough noodles instead of a crust.

HoneyBrown1976 3 years 31 weeks

Where's the both option? They are both good!! I voted pot pie, though.

Niami 3 years 31 weeks

I liked homemade pot pies, but the gluten-free versions (homemade or store bought) suck.

simplyfab87 3 years 31 weeks

Pot pies have always weirded me out. I really want to try shepherd's pie, it looks delicious.

kurniakasih 3 years 31 weeks

Unfair! I love 'em both. I can't be made to choose...:drool:

doogirl 3 years 31 weeks

Not fair! I love them both equally!

justanerd1975 3 years 31 weeks

I chose pot pie, but I really do like both so hard choice! :)

cupcake_ 3 years 31 weeks

I LOVE shepards pie!

CoconutPie 3 years 31 weeks

Chicken pot pie is my favorite! The Québec version of a Shepherd's pie is a close second though - ground beef + creamed corn + mashed potatoes (to be eaten with a lot of ketchup). :feedme: