Would You Rather Eat Pumpkin or Apple Pie?

November 4, 2007

by partysugar 71

Source

71 Comments

aimeeb 5 years 24 weeks

neither

FabulousNinu 5 years 27 weeks

i like both, but i have not had a pumpkin pie in sooooooooo long! it is just yummy!

mamaseacat 5 years 28 weeks

If there's nothing better, then I'll have either one.

michichan 5 years 28 weeks

caramel cheesecake please

sumnboutme 5 years 28 weeks

i don't like fruit pies but I'll take pumpkin, pecan or sweet potato!

motherof3 5 years 28 weeks

Lemon meringue is the only pie I like.

Too_Posh 5 years 28 weeks

I love Pumpkin, but I would rather have a slice of Chocolate Pecan Pie. It's amazing :D

carlabunnie 5 years 28 weeks

i heart Pumpkin Pie!

hyper somnia 5 years 28 weeks

Pumpkin pie with lots of whipped cream!

bellaraquela 5 years 28 weeks

raspberry is my favorite!

SugarFreak 5 years 28 weeks

Imma PECAN girl!

cageyme 5 years 28 weeks

Both, please! And can you make that a la mode?

mbrown81 5 years 28 weeks

Give me Pumpkin, Apple, Dutch Apple, Cherry, Rubarb, Strawberry, Southern Chess, Chocolate Cream, And many more.....

totonlaura 5 years 28 weeks

Pumpkin and Apple :FEEDME:!

Seraphim 5 years 28 weeks

i like ALL pies ;) lol

designergirl 5 years 28 weeks

Pumpkin pie! For some reason I really dislke double crust pies, so if the apple pie had a struesel topping or was a tart, it would be a toss-up.

yes jess 5 years 28 weeks

apple pie rules! pumpkin pie is just too smooshy for me.

kiwitwist 5 years 28 weeks

apple please.. I like pumpkin but only so much

krampalicious 5 years 28 weeks

pecan with chocolate chips (ghetto derby pie)!

splayer 5 years 28 weeks

My grandma's pecan pie... nothing like it in the world.

Soniabonya 5 years 28 weeks

I'm slowly enjoying the pumpkin pies. Ever since my roommate made it a couple years ago it perked my interest. But I do love the apple pies. If anyone is in San Diego County, go to the mountain town of Julian. they are famous for their apple pies!! Delicious. anytime friends found out we were going to Julian, we had a list of places to bbuy pies from to bring back.