Would You Rather Eat Tuna or Chicken Salad?

February 8, 2009

36 Comments

I wish there was a "Both!" option. I picked chicken salad because I will order that more than I'll order tuna if I am out at a restaurant for lunch, but I love to make both at home. I make them so differently that its hard to choose a favorite!

caramelqtee75 4 years 14 weeks

I luuuuv chicken salad - I should go get some for lunch today.

lindssaurussss 4 years 14 weeks

I hate chicken salad. but i will live off of tuna salad....seriously I had some today.

emalove 4 years 14 weeks

I love both, but I think I like tuna a little bit more.

dcfashionista 4 years 14 weeks

Both but I prefer Chicken salad.

ilanac13 4 years 14 weeks

i don't eat either, but i guess if i weren't a vegetarian (thinking back to when i was a kid) i would have to say that i was a tuna person and not a chicken salad person.

LoveSarah 4 years 14 weeks

I like both!

LoveSarah 4 years 14 weeks

I like both!

lola102 4 years 14 weeks

i LOVE chicken salad, and since i don't really love mayo I usually just put a tiny dab in and then lots of mustard and lemon pepper! it's delicious!

danixk 4 years 14 weeks

neither. they both smell like ass.

msshellokitty 4 years 14 weeks

chicken salad.i can't stand the taste of tuna.

iridescence 4 years 14 weeks

I've actually managed to live some 20 years without ever having chicken salad. I'm not particularly a fan of tuna, though, so I'd definitely have to pick the chicken. Haha.

Manoukia 4 years 14 weeks

Both, and I missed that option! Instead of mayo, I combine cream cheese and yoghurt, or feta and yoghurt, with lots of spices and herbs. I never use mayo anymore, but sometimes a little Miracle Whip, again mixed with yoghurt.

fiestamama 4 years 14 weeks

When ever I cook chicken breasts I cook a couple extra to make a grilled chicken salad.

aimeeb 4 years 14 weeks

Tuna :)

glampop20 4 years 14 weeks

I love both but I prefer chicken salad especially with cranberries and walnuts!

Spectra 4 years 14 weeks

Since I don't eat too many different types of fish, I like to eat tuna salad as a way to get in my oily fish. It's a lot easier to make than chicken salad and it's pretty tasty. I find chicken salad to be pretty bland usually.

PinkNC 4 years 14 weeks

I never eat mayo. So I would say tuna with lots of Miracle Whip salad dressing.

syako 4 years 14 weeks

I love a good chicken salad (has to be big chunks of chicken and fixins and minimal mayo). I've just never liked tuna. :?

HoneyBrown1976 4 years 14 weeks

I like both; but, I'd choose tuna over chicken.

wackdoodle 4 years 14 weeks

I would love to eat Tuna Salad but since my gastric bypass my stomach and small intestines cannot handle Tuna anymore. I get incredibly sick. And for a person who grew up eating Tuna in every imaginable way it is upsetting. So I switched to Chicken Salad and Turkey Salad. My digestive tract is okay with those too. I love my either Tuna, Chicken or Turkey salad with mayo, finely minced celery, minced red onion, a bit of scallion, diced tomato with the seeds removed, some seasoning but no celery seed, and sometimes if I want extra crunch shredded carrot. Oh yes ans a squeeze of fresh lemon juice and touch of spicy mustard.

MeggyPoodles 4 years 14 weeks

I like both, but I don't really ever buy them cause I HATE when they have chopped up celery in them. Thats pretty much a staple, so usually I stick to tuna sandwiches lol.