And the best candy of all time is . . . Reese's Peanut Butter Cups! Your favorite peanut-filled chocolate cups took top prize, with other chocolate contenders Twix, Snickers, and Peanut M&Ms vying for first place. The only nonchocolate candy to make it in the top five was Gummi Bears.
M&Ms might've lost out on this title, but it took home another: according to Yahoo, it was the top-searched candy in the month of October. Trailing closely behind? Candy corn, chewy caramels, Skittles, and Butterfinger.